Subscribe

The Pangs of Dispriz’d Love

The horrors of confession and possession in Curry Barker’s Obsession (2026)

The chilling “no, no, no” dinner scene in Curry Barker’s Obsession terrified the actress bringing it to life. Inde Navarrette revealed that she spent hours practicing those facial expressions in her mirror at home until she literally scared herself. Nikki is still in there, trapped, screaming, and fighting to reclaim her own body and mind.

Much like fellow comedian-turned-auteur Zach Cregger did with his hit film Weapons (2025), Curry Barker uses the stick-breaking device into a fresh and unsettling psychological horror in Obsession. It speaks directly to our basest instincts about love and control, forcing me to turn my late-night thoughts into this essay-review.

This film critic discusses suicide or self-harm in relation to the story.


I — Confession

There is a profound tragedy in words unsaid, when a lover’s confession is choked back by doubt, dither or dread. In Curry Barker’s Obsession, the protagonist, Bear, mishandles the delicate timing of confessing his love to Nicky. As he drives her home (having rehearsed his confession beforehand), the intimacy of the enclosed space prompted a rare moment of raw vulnerability: Nicky opens up, shifting the atmosphere into a fleeting span of profound friendship, tenderness, and buoyant optimism where she might have readily chosen him. But Bear, paralysed by the fear of being spurned, allows the silence to congeal. Out of his indecision, the golden, rosy chance is left to wither on the vine. The pregnant pause calcified into a permanent barrier.

To escape the anxiety of simply trying again (or risking rejection), Bear turns to the One Wish Willow, an innocuous-looking, hollowed-out, brown stick that grants one irrevocable wish once broken. “One” is to say the hairline window of opportunity to disclose one’s love—a single ticket to get it exactly right and, if bungled, eternally shuts the door to the prized romance. Pressured, perhaps fearing dismissal, in the heat of the moment, Bear reaches for an impetuous, mystical solution, striking a Faustian bargain with the shadowy shoots of the woods.

Though Bear remained incredulous of the powers of the willow’s fell branch, the wording of his wish (“I wish Nicky Freeman loved me more than anyone else in the fucking world”) was starkly solipsistic, totalising, and devoid of considerate love and care, but a desperate desire to wrest control of the crucial fading minutes. But the act, in a snap, placed Nicky (ironically named “Freeman”) under his spell.

In the wider conversation surrounding the film, many critics and audiences have roundly condemned Bear, viewing him through a modern lens as a deconstruction of the toxic “Nice Guy” archetype. To the community, Bear is a psychological villain who treats an independent woman as an object to be manipulated.

Yet, to diminish Bear as a flat, modern antagonist is to disregard the film’s more sophisticated dramatic elements. Bear is more accurately understood through the lens of a classic Aristotelian tragic hero, a fundamentally relatable, kindhearted figure whose catastrophic downfall is triggered by a profound error in judgment or an internal psychological blindness: their hamartia. Bear’s hamartia is his indecision and a craven need for control. When he snaps the branch, this wasn’t to further a grand plan of malice. But Bear is an ordinary man with understandable goals, succumbing to a fatal weakness that sets off a chain reaction (nemesis) that dooms both him and his crush.

In seeking a shortcut to an affection (which Nicky already harboured), Bear ultimately breaks it through the wishing willow. This tragedy extends to Sarah, whose own secret affection for Bear is permanently silenced by her abrupt murder. Her death is the ultimate collateral damage of Bear’s myopia, underscoring the lethal cost of his fixation on Nicky. Despite that, Bear is a complex, grey character, introduced as a visibly besotted, well-meaning nice guy, who transitions from the unknowing villain to a reluctant, tragic hero.

Bear and Nikki on their first night in bed, at Bear’s home.

II — Possession

The symbolism of the One Wish Willow is of glum portent. In Victorian literature, the weeping willow is heavily draped in the sorrow of unrequited love. Victorian poet Christina Rossetti, in In The Willow Shade, used the weeping willow to evoke the isolation of unreciprocated or unfulfilled passion. In Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Ophelia’s descent into madness and eventual drowning happens under a willow tree that “shows his hoar leaves in the glassy stream,” cementing the tree as the final resting place for a mind shattered by rejected love.

But Barker reaches deeper into Greek lore, where the willow is tethered to magic, Hecate, and the underworld. Willows naturally thrive in damp, liminal spaces, along the marshy banks and swampy borders, leading the ancients to believe they marked the physical boundaries of the Underworld. Hecate—the chthonic goddess of the night and the dark moon—is the patron of sorcery, poisons, and binding tablets (katadesmoi). In the ancient world, sorcery was distinct from common prayers, for they required humility as in entreating a god for favours and accepting a “no” for an answer. Sorcery, however, was an attempt to force the universe to obey one’s ego through incantations and witching objects. Orpheus, in search of Eurydice, carried a willow branch into the realm of the dead as protection; his harp, gifted by Apollo, was carved from its wood.

Meanwhile, the Willow in Obsession has the eerie qualities of a lifeless, pitted, plastic. Unlike the life-preserving tree of myths and lore, it is the conduit of malignant demons. And, as we saw past the story’s midpoint, it demands death.

With the willow granting Bear’s wish, the real Nicky ceased to exist; her body became only a vessel, indentured and robotic. The spellbound Nicky could simulate a partner’s ministrations, afford Bear her utmost zeal, moan doggedly during sex, and obey his inanities and caprices with limitless patience. When the demon possessed Nicky, it perfectly indulged Bear’s emotional starvation, but it could not love him.

The One Wish Willow as featured in the film. Source: Focus Features

III — Obsession

Here, Barker’s narrative invites a philosophical meditation. The four friends (Bear, Nicky, Ian & Sarah) work among musical instruments, objects that yield beautiful sound on command and feel nothing as they do, which is precisely what Bear makes of her. By robbing Nicky of her agency, Bear downgrades their dynamic in the manner that the existentialist Martin Buber warned against in Ich und Du (I and Thou): shifting from an authentic “I-Thou” encounter between free, equal subjects to a doomed “I-It” transaction. For a time, Bear took advantage of this boon. For a time, they seemed to be happily in sync. For a time, he believed it was real. But soon acknowledged in front of the possessed and obsessed Nicky, it was not. A contrived love is no love at all but a meaningless, sterile mimesis.

But what does it mean to be loved, and why does agency matter?

In Being and Nothingness, Sartre argued that to be loved is inherently paradoxical: we desire our partner to be a completely free, thinking subject who consciously chooses us, yet we simultaneously wish to bind them as an object that can, hopefully, never leave. But Sartre clarified that the lover does not want to possess the beloved as one would a property or an unthinking toy. If compliance is the sole determinant, one should only purchase a robot or program a sycophantic AI.

“The lover does not desire to possess the beloved as one possesses an object… He wants to possess freedom as freedom.”

—Jean-Paul Sartre, Being and Nothingness, 1943

Sartre’s lifelong intellectual partner, Simone de Beauvoir, wrote extensively about love in The Second Sex (1949). She argued that “authentic love must be founded on reciprocal recognition of two freedoms.” When Bear uses the Willow to strip Nicky’s agency, he isn’t just failing to love her but also failing to see her as his equal. This tension is epitomised in the film’s viral dinner scene. When Nicky’s consciousness short-circuits into the repetitive panic of “no, no, no,” the audience witnesses what Beauvoir called an act of existential violence. In Beauvoir’s framework, Bear has reduced Nicky from a “transcendence” (a free human being) into an “immanence” (a captive object). As actress Inde Navarrette noted in interviews, this moment is the heartbreaking sound of a real human mind trapped inside someone else’s fantasy, clawing to break through a supernatural veil of compliance.

Consequently, this relation is degraded into a lesser inauthentic bond, an enterprise rooted in what Sartre termed “bad faith” (mauvaise foi). Without two active freedoms operating in tandem, the relationship ceases to be a genuine human connection. According Beauvoir’s, this constitutes a “mutilated” love. Together, it is a compromised, lesser state of existence in which true intimacy becomes impossible, as the tension between two separate subjectivities has been erased.

Minutes before the wish, in the car, the real Nicky delivers a manifesto: “I don’t think romance is real… romance fades. Love is a different thing,” she says, she wants to write “the good, the bad, the ugly. Real shit,” not the magical lie.

We are wanting creatures, imperfect as we are, needing someone just as flawed to look at our deficits and, by their own uncoerced accord, choose us anyway. We don’t just want the person to say “I love you” mindlessly. We want them to mean it, to freely surrender their freedom to us. We want them to look at a million other paths they could take, a million other people they could be with, and choose us out of their own wild, unfettered thinking.

If that decision is forced by a memory implant or a supernatural curse, the essence of choosing (and love) vanishes. The subject becomes an object, a mechanical music box playing the most beautiful of melodies. The tunes are immaculate, but it isn’t singing to you, merely performing its code from the bumps of the cylinder.

(Left to Right) Bear, Sarah and Ian, during a “boy’s night out” party at Ian’s.

IV — Conclusion

It is a brilliant cinematic choice that the audience never gets to see the inside of Nicky’s or Sarah’s houses (a metaphor for their minds). The scenes remain with the boys, Bear and Ian. We saw Nicky about to enter hers, but Bear’s self-serving wish halted that. Nicky’s internal world is largely absent, except as relayed to Bear. By keeping the camera exclusively within the domains of Bear and Ian, Barker forces us to inhabit the confines of the male ego. When Nicky is shown about to enter her house, she is standing at the gateway of her own unreadable, independent life, only to be frozen mid-motion by Bear’s sweeping wish. Because she is barred from her own home, Nicky’s interiority is largely withdrawn from the film.

Obsession can be a film for the deconstruction of gendered power dynamics. It critiques the insidious way “well-meaning nice guys” project their own needs onto women, treating the female mind not as a sacred, guarded space with its own agency, but as a gender-coded blank screen seemingly meant only to mirror back their own thirst for validation. This is not to say that Bear had zero respect for Nicky’s autonomy, but the underlying logic of the wish suggests that this reductive attitude inherently surfaced in his mind at that point.

The uncomfortable truth is that, to some degree, we have all been Bear and the willow demon, playing both the captor and the captive in our personal histories with desire. We are all haunted by our memories of missteps—clumsy interactions in which we have misspoken, awfully miscommunicated, or, through a fatal combination of rash action or inaction, caused ourselves profound, lingering regret and self-loathing.

It is a universal human grief to look back at those missed moments and realise we have lost what mattered to us most, perhaps forever.

We may have acted primarily out of self-interest, preoccupied with the slipstream of our crude appetites, having ceased to see the other person as an independent soul (c’est juste moi). Instead, we surrender to the desperate, narcissistic want of a curated idea of them that satisfies our ego, thus blinding ourselves to the chaotic, radiant, and utterly incandescent human being standing right in front of us.

In Obsession, Bear appears to suffer from limerence, a psychological state that reduces Nicky from a person into a mere cure for his anxiety of wanting to be loved. Coined by psychologist Dorothy Tennov in the 1970s, limerence is an involuntary state of deep infatuation characterised by a desperate, obsessive need for one’s feelings to be reciprocated. Unlike genuine love, which focuses on the partner’s well-being and agency, limerence is entirely self-referential.

When the demonic trance momentarily breaks (which occurs at pivotal scenes of tenderness), Bear suffers the ultimate buyer’s remorse, enduring what Shakespeare famously called “the pangs of dispriz’d love.” He is vividly reminded that the woman looking back at him is not the Nicky he loves, but a reckless, horrific distortion born from his own wishful insecurity. His action and inaction condemned a potential romance (or love story) to a miserable third act of horror.

In the end, Bear’s character arc brings him full circle, transforming him from an unwitting, dewy-eyed villain into an unwilling, blood-soaked saviour. He reaches a point of anagnorisis: the realisation that his own cowardice has produced and prolonged this ordeal. He becomes a prisoner to the very obsession he wished for, depicted with Bear secluding himself in the commode about to take his life, while the possessed Nicky aggressively pounds the door.

After setting aside the pistol, Bear swallows lethal amounts of pills but attempts to frantically purge them later. As he vacillates between sacrifice and survival, another One Wish Willow is snapped off-camera, freezing his actions mid-throat. This sudden, supernatural fiat is a karmic irony of his arc: having stolen a woman’s agency in the first act, the universe strips him of his own in the third. He does not die a noble martyr but a helpless glove puppet to the Willow—a flawless execution of peripeteia (a sudden reversal of fortune). The ultimate consequence for Bear trying to play god over Nicky’s mind is that he is fed his own medicine (literally and figuratively).

Aristotle’s tragic hero is never the saint rewarded nor the villain punished, but the intermediate man ruined by his own error and seeing it too late. The blood of Sarah or Ian on Bear’s hands no more disqualifies him than Oedipus’s or Macbeth’s.

But the other irony of the One Wish Willow is that it brooks no second-guessing. It strips away Bear’s dithering and releases him from his hesitations and misgivings, forcing him to a moral epiphany. This is an idea he’d been cradling for a while, but lacked the mortal willpower to enact. Bear, unlike Nicky, was given the opportunity, the glimpse, before arriving at this conclusion. In his final moments, the poison coursing through his veins, he knows that to save the real Nicky—the independent, free-willed girl trapped inside the demon-possessed body—he must surrender his illusion of control. He must sacrifice himself so that his Nicky, the real Nicky he fell for, can live and thrive, even with him gone.

Barker avoids a romanticised Romeo-and-Juliet double death, leaving the surviving Nicky to wake into the wreckage. Bear’s sole semblance of redemption is externalised and involuntary. He frees Nicky from the curse but damns her to outlive the shambles.

A future cult classic and a triumph of thematic storytelling, Curry Barker’s Obsession lays bare the brutal, beautiful truth of what it means to love and be loved. Real love is not a possessive lock-and-key, but a radical act of self-abnegation, shared growth, and mutual sacrifice. Ultimately, the film demonstrates that true devotion is never found in trapping the one we desire, but in the absolute selflessness of setting them free.

Genre Horror, Mystery & Thriller 5/ 5