Subscribe

Heretic: Film Review

A thought-provoking movie to lose one’s religion | Dirs. Scott Beck & Bryan Woods, 2024

This review was originally published on Craccum on March 2025 (written on the second week of February) with the title “2024 of A24: A Review”.

Set in the Mormon heartland, we follow Paxton (Chloe East) and Barnes (Sophie Thatcher), two young missionaries on their quest to proselytise willing “investigators”. They visited a house owned by a religious sceptic, Mr Reed (Hugh Grant), hoping for another conversion—only to walk willingly inside his lair of traps, making them question their beliefs along the way. Mr Reed engages the pair in a dialogue, enticing the two with the scent of blueberry pie as he excavates deep-seated hypocrisies within the LDS church. He transposes it later to indict the broader Christian dogma as nothing but a glorified iteration of antiquated lores.

Mr Reed, who studied theology for decades, sought the “one true religion” and claims to have found it. In the course of their discussion, he floated hierological inconsistencies, citing Mormonism’s “cynical brainwashing tactic” to embrace polygamy only to discard it when convenient. This irreverently unspools Barnes and Paxton’s indoctrination, learning Mormonism reduced to Christianity’s “zany regional spinoff” and their missionary work as mere ad commercial.

This film reminds me of Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code (2006), except we’re not running around the Louvre but in the constraints of Mr Reed’s dimly lit house. It argues that religions are man’s fiction to imbue purpose in earthly living, banishing nihilistic demons from memory. Mr Reed, however, inadvertently reveals his own hypocrisy in an attempt to reify his “one true religion” by demonstrating a Eucharistic miracle. The finale is open to doubt, and that’s by design. As to the fate of Barnes and Paxton, we can simply take a leap of faith that they suffered better ends.

Genre Mystery & Thriller, Horror 3/ 5