Subscribe

Civil War: Film Review

A cautionary tale on war and the role of journalism | Dir. Alex Garland, 2024

This review was originally published on Craccum on March 2025 (written on the second week of February) with the title “2024 of A24: A Review”.

Released in a divisive US-election year, Civil War highlights the aftermath of a full-blown anarchy. Four journalists embarked on a road trip from New York to the White House to interview its incumbent (Nick Offerman) amidst the war-torn United States, hostile to pressmen. We heard, from their casual chatter, the Chief Executive’s decisions on pushing a third official term, dissolving the FBI and authorising air strikes on US citizens. This led to domestic fracturing, the petrodollar’s collapse and wide-scale disorder.

Garland pairing California and Texas, stereotypical bailiwicks of two rival parties allied against the Union, is particularly intriguing. Its meagre worldbuilding left audiences wondering about each faction’s motivation. He attempts to paint the belligerents devoid of their banners, presenting the struggle as an apolitical battle on which the stakes transcend partisan divide: the soul of the nation. Further, it does not wallow in the tension towards oncoming skirmishes; rather, at times, it plunges right into the thick of combat. While it may not appeal to many, it succeeds in disabusing us from romanticising war as nothing but an assault on the senses and being. Thus, we’re not meant to understand the casus belli as justification for the wider conflict moreso than its maddening aftermath.

Civil War studies a decaying State and journalism’s place amidst the bedlam. Lee Smith (Kirsten Dunst) contemplates the failure of her photojournalism to effectively dissuade the nation from self-destructing. It underlies opinions about present media, returning to its roots (symbolised in old film cameras), dispassionately relaying events as they are in still images without inserting themselves in the fray—something today’s US media outlets are criticised for doing. If there’s an overall message, perhaps it’s sic semper tyrannis.

Genre Action, War, Mystery & Thriller, Drama 3.4/ 5